22 Costco Items That Saw Price Hikes Up to 59% in Just Two Years

If you’re a regular Costco shopper, you’ve probably noticed that your favorite products are costing more than they used to. But have you checked the numbers? Some items have jumped in price by as much as 59% in just two years!

Here’s a closer look at 22 products at Costco Canada that have seen major price hikes since 2023—some of which might surprise you.

1. Kraft Peanut Butter – A Sticky Situation

• Current Price (2025): $10.49 (2 kg jar)
• 2023 Price: $8.89
• Price Increase: $1.60 (18% rise)

This creamy favorite has gone up significantly. That extra buck-sixty adds up, especially for peanut butter lovers buying in bulk.

2. Tetley Orange Pekoe Tea – The Brewing Price Surge

• Current Price (2025): $13.99 (945g box, 300 tea bags)
• 2023 Price: $11.99
• Price Increase: $2 (17% rise)

Your morning cup of tea is now a little more expensive. The price jump might not steep you out of buying, but it’s noticeable.

3. Kirkland Signature Cream Cheese – A Soft Price Spike

• Current Price (2025): $9.99 (4 x 250g blocks)
• 2023 Price: $9.49
• Price Increase: $0.50 (5% rise)

Even small price changes on essentials like cream cheese add up, especially if you’re using it for baking or spreads.

4. Kirkland Signature Ice Cream Bars – Sweet Price Increase

• Current Price (2025): $16.99 (18 bars)
• 2023 Price: $15.99
• Price Increase: $1 (6% rise)

If you’re stocking up for summer, be prepared to pay a little more for those creamy treats.

5. McCafe Coffee – A Minimal, But Noteworthy Rise

• Current Price (2025): $24.99 (1.36 kg canister)
• 2023 Price: $24.79
• Price Increase: $0.20 (1% rise)

This one’s almost unnoticeable, but every cent counts when you’re buying in bulk.

6. Kirkland Signature Coffee – A Bitter Price Hike

• Current Price (2025): $23.99 (1.13 kg bag)
• 2023 Price: $18.99 (907g bag)
• Price Increase: $5 (26% rise)

Not just the price but the per-100g cost has increased, making your morning brew more expensive than before.

16 Surprising Products That Are Cheaper at Costco Than Dollarama – You Won’t Believe the Savings!

Best Costco Groceries for Smaller Households

27 Items That Are More Affordable at Costco Compared to Grocery Stores in Canada

Here’s how you can get a free Costco gift card deal in Canada!

7. Kirkland Signature Hazelnut Spread – Nutty Price Jump

• Current Price (2025): $13.49 (2-pack, 1 kg jars)
• 2023 Price: $12.99
• Price Increase: $0.50 (4% rise)

For those who love spreading the joy (literally), this price bump might sting a bit.

8. Tim Hortons Coffee – A Brew-tifully Expensive Change

• Current Price (2025): $23.99 (1.36 kg canister)
• 2024 Price: $19.99
• Price Increase: $4 (20% rise)

This one’s a major jump, especially for Canadians loyal to Tim’s.

9. Costco Croissants – A Flaky Price Increase

• Current Price (2025): $7.99 (825g pack)
• 2023 Price: $6.99
• Price Increase: $1 (14% rise)

A dollar more for buttery, flaky croissants? Worth it? Depends on how much you love your morning pastry.

10. Costco Cookies – Sweet, But Pricier

• Current Price (2025): $10.99 (1.07 kg pack)
• 2023 Price: $9.99
• Price Increase: $1 (10% rise)

Cookies aren’t just for snacks anymore—they’re part of the budget crunch.

11. Kirkland Signature Popcorn – Popping Prices

• Current Price (2025): $20.99 (4.1 kg box)
• 2023 Price: $19.99
• Price Increase: $1 (5% rise)

Perfect for movie nights, but your snack budget just grew.

12. Kirkland Signature Chocolate-Dipped Granola Bars – A Sweet 33% Jump

• Current Price (2025): $15.99 (1.49 kg box)
• 2024 Price: $11.99
• Price Increase: $4 (33% rise)

This is one of the biggest jumps on the list, with a huge 33% increase.

13. Kirkland Signature Chocolate Chip Granola Bars – A Slight Rise

• Current Price (2025): $12.99 (1.54 kg box)
• 2024 Price: $11.99
• Price Increase: $1 (8% rise)

Not as dramatic as the chocolate-dipped bars, but still noticeable.

14. Kirkland Signature Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies – Crumbly Price Hike

• Current Price (2025): $17.49 (850g box)
• 2024 Price: $15.99
• Price Increase: $1.50 (9% rise)

Tiny cookies, big price jump.

15. Kirkland Signature Steak Strips – A Meaty Price Increase

• Current Price (2025): $16.99 (340g bag)
• 2024 Price: $14.99
• Price Increase: $2 (13% rise)

For jerky lovers, this is a tough bite.

16. Kirkland Signature Marinara Sauce – A Saucy Price Rise

• Current Price (2025): $19.99 (3 x 860 ml jars)
• 2023 Price: $17.99
• Price Increase: $2 (11% rise)

Pasta night just got pricier.

17. Kraft Dinner – The Budget Mac & Cheese Gets Costlier

• Current Price (2025): $15.99 (12 boxes)
• 2023 Price: $14.99
• Price Increase: $1 (7% rise)

The ultimate comfort food, now with a little extra comfort for the grocery store.

18. Kirkland Signature Tuna – A Fishy Price Increase

• Current Price (2025): $16.99 (8 x 184g cans)
• 2023 Price: $15.99
• Price Increase: $1 (6% rise)

Still affordable, but every cent adds up.

19. Kirkland Signature Olive Oil – A Shocking 59% Surge

• Current Price (2025): $34.99 (2L bottle)
• 2023 Price: $21.99
• Price Increase: $13 (59% rise)

This is the biggest jump on the list. If you cook with olive oil, brace yourself.

20. Scotties Tissues – A Tissue Price Sneeze

• Current Price (2025): $26.99 (20 boxes)
• 2024 Price: $24.99
• Price Increase: $2 (8% rise)

A little more to wipe away your worries.

21. Kirkland Signature Toilet Paper – A Roll of Inflation

• Current Price (2025): $23.99 (30 rolls)
• 2023 Price: $21.49
• Price Increase: $2.50 (12% rise)

Because the bathroom budget matters too.

22. Mr. Clean All-Purpose Cleaner – A Clean Price Climb

• Current Price (2025): $13.49 (5.2 L bottle)
• 2023 Price: $12.49
• Price Increase: $1 (12% rise)

You’ll need this to clean up after the price shock.

Final Thoughts: Are These Price Increases Worth It?

Costco has always been known for its bulk deals and savings, but it’s clear that inflation has touched even the most budget-friendly products. While some price hikes are modest, others—like the 59% increase in olive oil—are hard to ignore.