A new online petition has gained significant traction, with over 5,600 signatures, calling on the UK Government to abolish the Basic State Pension and transition all current recipients to the New State Pension. The petition’s creator, Michael Thompson, further proposes increasing the New State Pension to a “substantial percentage of average earnings” to better support retirees in their later years.
As of the latest Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) figures, approximately 13 million people are claiming the State Pension, with 4.1 million receiving the New State Pension, which applies to those who started claiming post-April 2016. Meanwhile, 8.8 million individuals continue to receive the Basic (or Old) State Pension, which applies to those who reached State Pension age before April 2016. The upcoming April 7th increase to pension payments will rise by 4.1%, in accordance with the Triple Lock mechanism.
Table of Contents
Petition Advocates for Equality in State Pension Payments
The petition, titled “Abolish the Basic State Pension, Increase the New State Pension, and Pay to All”, argues that individuals on the Basic State Pension should receive the difference between their payments and those of New State Pension recipients. This call for reform is rooted in the belief that the current system of separate pension tiers creates an unfair divide between pensioners based on when they became eligible.
Currently, people on the full New State Pension will see their weekly payments rise by £9.05, from £221.20 to £230.25. Over a four-week payment period, this amounts to £921, translating to an annual increase of £473.60. However, it’s crucial to note that not everyone receiving the New State Pension gets the full amount, as it’s linked to National Insurance contributions. Meanwhile, individuals on the full Basic State Pension will see a weekly increase of £6.95, from £169.50 to £176.45, raising their four-weekly payment to £705.80 and their annual payments by £361.40.
The Case for Equalizing State Pension Rates
The argument for moving everyone to the New State Pension stems from the belief that the current system is outdated and inherently unfair. Many Basic State Pension recipients, particularly those who were contracted out of the Additional State Pension, are effectively receiving a lower amount than their peers who are on the New State Pension. This disparity is seen as an issue of equality and fairness, especially when some pensioners are living on substantially lower incomes in retirement.
Thompson’s petition specifically calls for the gap in pension payments to be bridged, stating that individuals who were on the Basic State Pension before the 2016 reform should be compensated for the difference in their pension amounts compared to those receiving the New State Pension.
Government Response to the Petition and Pension Disparity
At present, the UK Government, through the Department for Work and Pensions, has made it clear that direct comparisons between the two systems are not straightforward. Pensions Minister Torsten Bell noted in a response to a parliamentary query that the two pension systems reflect different National Insurance contribution histories and additional factors such as Additional State Pension benefits or workplace pensions for those contracted out of the scheme.
The government has also reaffirmed its commitment to the Triple Lock, ensuring that State Pension payments are set to rise in line with earnings, inflation, or 2.5%, whichever is highest. For the 2025/26 financial year, a 4.1% increase has already been confirmed, boosting the pensions of those on both the Basic and New State Pensions.
DWP Announces Older Individuals Can Claim £4,200 State Pension Increase Online in Only 16 Minutes
1.3 Million Faces Losing Sickness Benefits as DWP Introduces New Eligibility Criteria
Sky Broadband Outage Leaves Customers Frustrated: Internet and Wi-Fi Issues Across the UK
DWP Urged to Introduce ‘Back to Work’ Offer for Benefits Claimants Seeking Employment
Calls to Raise State Pension Payments to £1,700 per Month
The Economic Impact of Pension Changes
If the petition reaches 10,000 signatures, the UK Government would be required to provide a written response. At 100,000 signatures, the petition could be considered for debate in Parliament. The debate around pensions is becoming increasingly relevant as the cost of living rises and pensioners struggle to keep pace with inflation.
Recent reports from the financial services company Royal London highlight that around half of the people receiving the New State Pension are not getting the full weekly amount, with some individuals receiving as little as £100 per week. This has sparked a broader conversation about whether the state pension system is sufficient to meet the needs of modern retirees, particularly in an era of rising living costs and economic uncertainty.
Future Projections and Challenges
Looking ahead, the government has committed to maintaining the Triple Lock for the remainder of the current Parliament, meaning that pensioners will continue to see regular increases in their State Pension payments. Projections for future increases include a rise of 2.5% annually from 2026 to 2030, but questions remain as to whether this will be enough to address the growing financial pressures faced by pensioners.
The ongoing debate over pension equality highlights the need for a comprehensive review of the State Pension system. The call to “abolish the Basic State Pension” and provide a more generous and equitable solution to all retirees has gained significant public attention, but it remains to be seen whether policymakers will act on this growing demand for reform.
As pension payments rise each year, the gap between the Basic and New State Pensions continues to provoke debate, with many calling for a system that offers fairer, more adequate support to all pensioners. Whether the UK Government will heed these calls remains uncertain, but with increasing public support for pension reform, the issue is unlikely to disappear anytime soon.